McGraw-Hill OnlineMcGraw-Hill Higher EducationLearning Center
Student Center | Instructor Center | Information Center | Home
Chapter Objectives
Issues and Applications
Theories
Philosophers
Glossary
Feedback
Help Center


Doing Philosophy: An Introduction Through Thought Experiments, 2/e
Theodore Schick, Muhlenberg College
Lewis Vaughn

The Problem of Personal Identity

Theories

Animalism



Harold Noonan: Arguments Against Animalism
(http://host.uniroma3.it/progetti/kant/field/bakersymp_noonan.htm)

Article by Harold Noonan against animalism
Lynne Rudder Baker: Reply to Noonan
(http://host.uniroma3.it/progetti/kant/field/bakersymp_replytonoonan.htm)

Reply to Noonan's paper by Lynne Rudder Baker (University of Massachusetts)
Thinking Animals and the Constitution View
(http://host.uniroma3.it/progetti/kant/field/bakersymp_olson.htm)

A defense of animalism by one of its most prominent proponents, Eric Olson (Churchill College, Cambridge)
Survival of the Sentient
(http://www.nyu.edu/gsas/dept/philo/faculty/unger/papers/survival.pdf)

A critique of animalism by Peter Unger (New York University)
The Bounds of Agency within the Unity of Consciousness
(http://www.uwmanitowoc.uwc.edu/staff/awhite/MARKB.4.htm)

A critique of both animalism and the psychological continuity theory by Mark Brown (University of Wisconsin)
Lectures on Personal Identity
(http://www.dur.ac.uk/philosophy.department/modules/kandr/njcs/PI.HTM)

Lecture notes comparing Parfit's theory with animalism (University of Durham)

The Soul Theory



The Immateriality of the Soul and Personal Identity
(http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/locke/supplement.html)

Supplemental article from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Thought Experiments and the Soul
(http://www.friesian.com/soul.htm)

Article by Kelly L. Ross (Los Angeles Valley College)
The Soul in Roy Bhaskar's Thought
(http://www.damaris.org/dcscs/readingroom/2001/collier1.htm)

An account of various notions of the soul by Andrew Collier (University of Southampton)
How Does Your Soul Fit Into Your Brain?
(http://www.abarnett.demon.co.uk/atheism/brain.html)

Article by Adrian Barnett on the relationship between the brain and the soul
Arguments Supporting Reincarnation
(http://www.wisdomworld.org/additional/ListOfCollatedArticles/ArgueForReincarnation.html)

Article by William Q. Judge defending reincarnation

The Memory Theory



Self and Identity as Memory
(http://ist-socrates.berkeley.edu/~kihlstrm/SelfIdentityMemory.htm)

Article by John F. Kihlstrom & Jennifer S. Beer Stanley B. Klein (University of California at Berkeley)
The Memory Theory: Logical Worries
(http://www.unc.edu/~theis/phil20/logicalprobs.html)

Lecture notes by Ben Theis (University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill)
Persistence through Time for Persons
(http://philarete.home.mindspring.com/philosophy/personal.html)

Article evaluating Locke's memory theory by Carl Brock Sides
The Continuity Argument
(http://www.stanford.edu/~pxwang/Williams.pdf)

Defense of the memory theory by Philip Wang (Stanford University)
Locke's Theory of Personal Identity
(http://easyweb.easynet.co.uk/~ursa/philos/prel2.htm)

Article by Peter B. Lloyd
Locke, Book II
(http://faculty.washington.edu/himma/phil3604/trans012.htm)

Lecture notes on Locke's theory of personal identity by Ken Himma (University of Washington)

The Brain Theory



The Diachronic Self
(http://www.maxmore.com/disscont.htm)

Dissertation on personal identity by Max Moore (Extropy Institute)
Brain Transplants
(http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/today/reports/science_nature/brain.shtml)

Article on the possibility of brain transplants by BBC news.
Dualism: An Empirical Test
(http://users.ox.ac.uk/~shil0124/mystuff/dualism.html)

Implications of brain transplants for theories of the self by Peter J. King (University of North London)

Closest Continuer Theory



Personal Survival and the Closest Continuer Theory
(http://www.eou.edu/~jjohnson/personalsurvival.htm)

Article by Jeff Johnson (Eastern Oregon University)
Causal Conditions of Continuity
(http://www.maxmore.com/chapter1.htm)

Discussion of the closest continuer theory by Max Moore (Extropy Institute)
Maintaining Identity
(http://www.mind.ilstu.edu/misc/WinPhilp/PhillipsCh5.doc?class=phi315a¤t=23)

Chapter from Win Phillip's masters thesis maintained by the Mind Project
Recent Work on Identity through Time
(http://fas-philosophy.rutgers.edu/~sider/papers/recent_work_on_identity.htm)

Article by Theodore Sider (Syracuse University)

Psychological Continuity Theory



Parfit, Lewis, Sperry, and Leibniz on Identity and Survival
(http://philosophy.wisc.edu/marshall/parfit.pdf)

Defense of the Psychological Continuity theory by Eugene Marshall (University of Wisconsin)
Relation R and the Question of Causationf
(http://www.dur.ac.uk/Philosophical.Writings/FormattingEG.pdf)

Defense of the psychological continuity theory by G. J. Shipley
Parfit on Survival
(http://www.princeton.edu/~jimpryor/courses/intro/notes/parfit.html)

Lecture notes by James Pryor (Princeton University)
A Metaphysical Manifesto for Translated Travelers
(http://www.bkmarcus.com/docs/manifesto.html)

Evaluation of Parfit's theory as it applies to the prospect of teletransportation by Brian Knatz
All the World's a Stage
(http://fas-philosophy.rutgers.edu/~sider/papers/stage.html)

Defense of a 4-dimensional view of persons by Theodore Sider (University of Rochester)