Student View | Instructor Center | Information Center View | Home
The Mechanical Design Process, 3/e
Student View
Aphorism List

Chapter Summary

Feedback
Help Center



Concept Evaluation

Chapter Summary

  • The feasibility of a concept is based on the design engineer's knowledge. Often it is necessary to augment this knowledge with the development of simple models.
  • In order for a technology to be used in a product, it must be ready. Six measures of technology readiness can be applied.
  • A go/no-go screening based on customers' requirements helps filter the concepts.
  • The decision-matrix method provides means of comparing and evaluating concepts. The comparison is between each concept and a datum relative to the customers' requirements. The matrix gives insight into strong and weak areas of the concepts. The decision-matrix method can be used for subsystems of the original problem.
  • The advanced decision matrix method leads to robust decisions by including the effects of uncertainty, incompleteness, and evolution in the decision-making process.
  • Belief maps are a simple yet powerful way to evaluate alternatives and work to gain team consensus.
  • Product safety implies concern for injury to humans and for damage to the device itself, other equipment, or the environment.
  • Safety can be designed into a product, it can be added on, or the hazard can be warned against. The first of these is best.
  • A hazard assessment is easy to accomplish and gives good guidance.