Policies regarding dividends and repurchases, relate to framing. In the traditional
MM approach, people are assumed to be impervious to framing effects. In the
behavioral approach, mental accounting and hedonic editing feature framing
effects that lead individual investors to find dividends especially attractive.
Older, retired investors find dividends attractive because they view dividends
as a replacement for wage and salary income. Young, employed investors find
dividends attractive because regular dividends make it easier for them to tolerate
risk. Managers have developed heuristics to set dividend policies in order
to meet investors’ psychological
needs. Those heuristics involve smoothing. Managers who set dividend policies
with investors’ needs
in mind are said to cater to investors. Share repurchases are not psychologically
equivalent to dividends. In this respect, managers also think about share
repurchases differently than they think about dividends. Share repurchases
need not be regular, whereas dividend payouts entail much more of a commitment
to regularity. Prices are impacted by changes in dividend policy and share
repurchases. Many of these impacts give rise to price inefficiencies, notably
drift effects. Markets underreact to both dividend omissions and dividend
initiations, and the strength of the price impact is twice as large in the
case of omissions. Markets also underreact to share repurchases. |