McGraw-Hill OnlineMcGraw-Hill Higher EducationLearning Center
Student Center | Instructor Center | Information Center | Home
Chapter Objectives
Issues and Applications
Theories
Philosophers
Glossary
Flashcards
True or False
Multiple Choice Quiz
Essay Quiz
Thought Probes
Feedback
Help Center


Doing Philosophy: An Introduction Through Thought Experiments, 2/e
Theodore Schick, Muhlenberg College
Lewis Vaughn

Free Will and Determinism
The Luck of the Draw: Freedom as Chance

Thought Probes

The Devil Made Me Do It: The law recognizes many types of excuses for criminal behavior. What do you think should distinguish a legitimate excuse from an illegitimate one?

Emerging Defenses to Crime
(http://faculty.ncwc.edu/toconnor/excuse.htm)

List of legal justifications, excuses, mitigations
Sleepwalking - Nightmare for the courts
(http://www.colorado.edu/iec/SP200RW/sleep.htm)

Sleepwalking as a legal defense
Forensic Psychiatry & Medicine
(http://www.forensic-psych.com/articles/artRebirth.html)

Forensic Psychiatry and legal defenses
True Legal/Courtroom Humor
(http://www.voiceone.com/html/legal.html#Just%20Because%20God%20Forgives%20You...)

Collection of strange cases from the Harris Creative Group
Freedom and Foreknowledge: If God knows the future, can we have free will?

Omniscience and Human Freedom
(http://comp.uark.edu/~senor/OmniFree.html)

Article by Thomas Senor (University of Arkansas) articulating the problem and exploring possible solutions
Divine Omniscience and Human Freedom
(http://twtministries.com/articles/9_openness/divine.html)

Article by Donald H. Wacome defending the view that God is not omniscient
Omniscience vs. Free Will
(http://home.earthlink.net/~kirby/xtianity/freewill.html)

Article (with responses) by Peter Kirby arguing that the traditional God of theism cannot exist
The Logical Incompatibility Between Free Will and Omniscience
(http://members.telocity.com/mcpierce/freewill.html)

Article by Darryl L. Pierce arguing that omniscience is impossible
Omniscience and Freedom: A Case for the Opposition
(http://www.valdosta.edu/~rbarnett/phi/free.html)

Handout from Ron Barnette (Valdosta University)
The Book of Life: Suppose a perfect predictor super wrote a book chronicling every moment of your life. Could you do otherwise than what is written?

Agency and Omniscience
(http://sun.soci.niu.edu/~phildept/Kapitan/omniagent.html)

Article by Thomas Kapitan from Religious Studies (1991) arguing that omniscience is incompatible with free agency
Free Will
(http://www.rationality.net/freewill.htm)

Article by Walter E. Requadt from rationality.net arguing that there couldn't be a perfect predictor because of randomness
Free Will Contradicts the Idea of an Omniscient God
(http://www.abarnett.demon.co.uk/atheism/freewill.html)

Discussion by Adrian Barnett arguing that nothing can be omniscient
John Calvin: On Predestination
(http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/mod/calvin-predest.html)

Selection from Calvin's Institutes of the Christian Religion (The Modern History Sourcebook, Fordham University)
Defending Determinism: Is determinism self-refuting?

Some Ways to Critique a Worldview
(http://www.afterall.net/citizens/choi/papers/worldviewcritique.html)

Article by Sean Choi identifying criteria of adequacy for world views
Arguments that Commit Suicide
(http://www.str.org/free/solid_ground/SG0107.htm)

Article by Gregory Koukl from Stand to Reason identifying arguments that are self-referentially inconsistent
Materialism is Self-refuting
(http://www.mosquitonet.com/~prewett/materialism.html)

Excerpt from C.S. Lewis's Miracles
Science/Religion
(http://www.johnhick.org.uk/article5.shtml)

Speech by John Hick (Claremont Graduate University) arguing that physicalism is self-refuting
C.S. Lewis' Teleological Argument
(http://faculty.winthrop.edu/craigheadh/articles/csl.htm)

Article by Houston A. Craighead (Winthrop University) defending Lewis' claim that naturalism is self-refuting
Genetic Cleansing: Should we use genetic engineering to alter our psychological make-up?

BLTC Research
(http://www.bltc.com/)

Mission Statement of an organization devoted to altering the human genome to eliminate suffering
Council for Responsible Genetics
(http://www.gene-watch.org/)

Home page of an organization dedicated to fostering public debate about the ethical and environmental implications of genetic technology
Human Genetic Engineering
(http://www.human-genetic-engineering.com/)

Introduction by human-genetic-engineering.com
Reproductive Genetics Resource Center
(http://www.arhp.org/healthcareproviders/resources/genetics/index.cfm?ID=293)

Articles on all aspects of genetic engineering
Human Genetic Engineering
(http://www.probe.org/docs/humgeneng.html)

Article by Dr. Ray Bohlin exploring the pros and cons from a Christian perspective
Human Genetic Engineering
(http://www.gyre.org/news/explore/Human+Genetic+Engineering)

Set of links provided by gyre.com
Genetic Engineering and Its Dangers
(http://online.sfsu.edu/~rone/GEessays/gedanger.htm)

Set of links provided by Ron Epstein (San Francisco State University)
Newcomb's Paradox: Consider the deal described on page 188. Would you choose option (1) or option (2)?

Newcombiana Applications
(http://www.philosophy.unimelb.edu.au/handouts/161033/newtan.html)

of Newton's paradox to nuclear war
Newcomb's Paradox
(http://members.aol.com/kiekeben/newcomb.html)

Article by Franz Kiekeben considering various solutions and presenting his own
Quantum Solution to Newcomb's Paradox
(http://alpha.uwb.edu.pl/ep/RePEc/sla/eakjkl/10.pdf)

Article by Edward W. Piotrowski (University of Bialtystok) using quantum mechanics to solve the paradox
Paradoxes or Fallacy
(http://www.paradoxes.info/NewcombsParadox.html)

Analysis of Newcomb's paradox by Andrew McMillan
Unlimited Room for Thought
(http://www.thegline.com/thought/2001/09-28-2001.htm)

Article by the Gline exploring the implications of Newcomb's paradox for education