Site MapHelpFeedbackChapter 4 - Essay Exercise 3-B
Chapter 4 - Essay Exercise 3-B
(See related pages)

Read this paragraph and answer the questions that follow.

The general European view is that English is an illogical, chaotic language, unsuited for clear thinking, and it is easy to understand this view, for no other European language admits of such shoddy treatment. Yet, on the other hand, none other admits of such poetic exquisiteness, and often the apparent chaos is only the untidiness of a workshop in which a great deal of repair and other work is in progress: the benches are crowded, the corners piled with lumber, but the old workman can lay his hands on whatever spare parts or accessories he needs, or at least on the right tools and materials for improvising them. French is a language of fixed models: it has none of this workshop untidiness and few facilities for improvisation. In French, one chooses the finished phrase nearest to one's purpose, and, if there is nothing that can be "made to do," a long time is spent getting the Works--the Academy --to supply or approve a new model. Each method has its own advantages. The English method tends to ambiguity and obscurity of expression in any but the most careful writing; the French to limitation of thought.

--author unknown

1
The method of development in this paragraph is analogy. Indicate the terms of the analogy (what is compared to what).
2
Explain what the analogy means.
3
Literally, who is the "old workman" referred to in the paragraph?
4
According to the writer, what is the primary disadvantage of English?
5
And what is the main advantage of English?
6
Finally, what is the main disadvantage of French?







Developing Critical Reading SkOnline Learning Center

Home > Chapter 4 > Essay Exercise 3-B