Student View | Instructor View | Information Center View | Home
Critical Thinking
Student View

Chapter Outline
Multiple Choice Quiz
True or False
Glossary
Web Links
PowerPoint Tutorials

Feedback
Help Center



Analyzing Arguments

Chapter Outline

Following are the main learning objectives from the chapter.

Students should understand the importance of, and be proficient in, the analysis of arguments. To this end, students should . . .


Be proficient in diagramming short arguments

(See pgs. 189-197)

Further, students should be able to . . .

A. Recognize when premises provide independent support for a conclusion.

B. Recognize when premises provide linked support (interdependent support) for a conclusion.

Be proficient in summarizing longer arguments

(See pgs. 200-214)

To this end, students should . . .

A. Become adept in paraphrasing passages. Students should learn to . . .

1. paraphrase passages accurately;

2. paraphrase passages clearly;

3. paraphrase passages concisely;

4. paraphrase passages charitably.

B. Be able to recognize missing premises and conclusions (i.e. be able to complete enthymemes). Students should learn to . . .

1. faithfully interpret arguers' intentions;

2. charitably interpret arguers' intentions.

C. Be proficient in the method of argument standardization.

1. locate the main conclusion, subconclusions and other premises in the argument;

2. omit unnecessary or irrelevant material;

3. arrange the premises and conclusion in their logical order;

4. fill in missing premises or conclusions;

5. add parenthetical justifications for each conclusion in the argument.

6. learn to avoid common mistakes in standardizing arguments.