|
| Consumers Eric Arnould,
University of Nebraska George Zinkhan,
University of Georgia Linda Price,
University of Nebraska
The Self and Selves
eLearning Session- Learning Objectives
After completing this chapter, you should be able to: - Know the characteristics of self-concept and understand more about how
you characterize yourself and how others are likely to describe you.
- Recognize the I-self, the me-self, and the looking glass self.
- Explain how self-concept affects intrapersonal processes such as self-narrative,
information processing of self-relevant information, and the regulation
of affect.
- Describe how self-concept affects interpersonal processes such as lifestyle,
interaction strategy and interpersonal influence.
- Discuss the relationship between people's self-concepts and their consumption
behavior, including relating self-concept to the circle of consumption.
- Recognize how the self-concept varies cross-culturally.
- Explain the relationship between personality traits and self-concept and
discuss applications of personality theory to consumer behavior.
- Chapter Overview
- Self-Concept
- One way to begin thinking about self-concept is to respond to this request:
"Tell me about yourself."
- A normal and important aspect of social exchanges is a sharing of information
about selves. You may notice several interesting things about your own responses
to this question.
- Self-concept Is Multi-Faceted
- Self-concept Depends On Situations and Movies
- You might observe that your response to the invitation, "Tell me
about yourself,"depends on situations and motives. Some research
suggests that individuals focus on whatever aspects of him or herself that
are most relevant in a particular social setting or situation. Consumer
researchers term this idea our working or activated, self-concept. Culture,
gender, ethnic and other characteristics of identity become significant
to consumers in particular circumstances. For example, when marketers invite
consumers to attend to them as in the ads that focus on African-American
pride, or when we find ourselves in a consumption context that brings them
into view.
- Marketers and policy makers should be sensitive to how different self-concepts
get activated in social situations. In some university communities, not
drinking alcohol is a distinctive consumer behavior, and thus becomes a
relevant dimension of self-concept.
- We selectively retrieve different aspects of our self-concept depending
on goals and motives.
- During a single day, as situations change a consumer may desire to represent
self either publicity or privately in a variety of different ways through
consumption. Fashion offers a way to express different aspects of the self
and helps us create and represent different identities.
- Depending on the situation, consumption may activate different aspects
of the self. Setting out the crystal wine glasses for a dinner party may
activate self-schemas of pride and competence, creating both memories and
expectations. Sometimes consumers may contrive to use products to trigger
aspects of the self. For example, you may have noticed that the clothes
you wear subtly change your body language. Marketers position products to
take advantage of the power of products to activate aspects of the self.
- Behavioral Constraints and Possible Selves
- When you think about your response to the request, "Tell me about
yourself" you might observe that your own behavior is constrained
by factors other than your self-concept. For example, you may describe
yourself as fun loving and carefree, but have trouble (especially during
exams) remembering the last time those self-qualities were reflected in
your behavior.
- As a consequence of restrictions on our behavior, self-concept will not
always be directly revealed in behavior. Its impact may be revealed more
indirectly in mood changes, in what aspects of self-concept are dominant
and accessible, in the nature of self-presentation, and the choice of social
setting.
- Thus, one way of thinking about self-concept is that it is composed of
self-representations or self-schemas, each consisting of a system
of knowledge structures organized in memory and consisting of self-relevant
information, including ideas and information about others and things.
Some representations are positive, some negative. Consumers are aware of
some self-representations while they are unaware of others either because
they are fairly automatic or because they are repressed in daily life. For
marketers, these constraints on self-expression may modify the relationships
between expressions of self and consumption behaviors. By identifying barriers
to self-expression marketers can develop or position products and services
to alleviate them.
- Self-representations may refer to actual I-selves and also to possible
selves-selves we could be, would like to be, or are afraid of becoming.
Possible selves consist of self-schemas created for domains of activity
that give personal meaning to the past and the future. People are likely
to attribute certain consumption behaviors to these possible selves, both
positive and negative.
- Possible selves may refer to past, present or future views of self.
- Some self-schemas refer to the "ought" self-the self we think
that we should be. Diet, self-help, and exercise products and services often
appeal to this "ought" self.
- Because of the existence of possible selves and different working selves,
consumers may have conflicted self-conceptions. Some research suggests that
conflicted self-representations can cause emotional disorders, anxiety and
depression. However, other research suggests that complex self-conceptions
and multiple identities can lead to better mental health. Part of the key
seems to be whether or not the identities can be successfully integrated
with each other. Often purchases and possessions can help facilitate and
integrate different aspects of the self.
- Marketers can develop new product positioning by identifying key problems
of self-integration and designing products that help consumers do this.
An example is high quality packaged convience foods that integrate a woman's
self as nurturing mother and self as high achieving corporate executive.
- Self-concept is Changeable
- The Dynamic Self-concept
- Intrapersonal Processes
- The working self-concept regulates intrapersonal processes in several
important ways. First, the self-concept integrates and organizes an individual's
self-relevant experiences into a self-narrative. Self-narratives
consistof stories that are coherent, context sensitive accounts
of experiences that provide a sense of personal continuity in time and space.
These stories often refer to events past, present and future; they contain
a judgmental or evaluative component, and are woven together to appear coherent
to the storyteller. Often people use consumption to give coherence to their
stories about self.
- Often people use consumption to give coherence to their stories about
the self.
- Consumers also may use consumption to create new self-narratives and change
self-concept. A tattoo artist describing his clients' motivations for getting
tattoos in Consumer Chronicles 7.4 provides one example of the relationship
between using consumption and self-narrative to change self-concept during
a role transition.
Consumer Chronicles 7.4: Tattooing and a New Sense of Self (50.0K) - Second, self-concept influences the processing of self-relevantinformation. Self-relevant information is defined in terms of internalized
self-schemas that represent a reference value or standard of comparison
for new information from the environment. Consumers' attention to self-relevant
information is guided by the need for self-consistency, or the need to maintain
a balance between self-image and behaviors ascribed to the self. In other
words, people pay attention to information including marketing communications
that reinforces self-concept. Individuals are more sensitive to information
that is self-relevant. Self-relevant information is more efficiently processed;
and people remember and recognize self-relevant information better. Finally,
consumers are resistant to information that is incongruent with their self-representations.
- It is important for marketers to understand the effect of product self-relevance
on self-concept and processing of information. Any kind of brand or product
category that becomes a widely recognized symbol of particular kinds of
people, say Tommy Hilgfiger fashions and hip hop stars or Hickey Freeman
suits and business executives, leads people to adopt such product symbols
as a vehicle to create their own possible selves.
- Self-relevance is likely to be an important determinant of consumer involvement
with, and processing of, marketing communications. Because people attend
to self-relevant information, many studies suggest that a personalized advertising
approach should attract subscribers' attention.
- Self-concept influences the regulation of affect. Individuals
defend their self-concepts against negative emotional states and interact
with others and interpret events in ways that enhance and promote their
self-concept. Many studies have documented self-serving biases in how individuals
interpret events. One way that people regulate negative affect is by reducing
self-awareness.
- Some related recent research has focused on self-gifts.
Many Euro-Americans give themselves presents, that is, they think of certain
purchases or consumption activities as "gifts for me." Often,
these presents help people regulate their emotional balance.
- Self-concept has important effects on motivation. In considering the effect
of self-concept on motivation, recall that self-concept includes many images
of possible selves (feared and desired). A particularly important subset
of a person's possible selves is desired selves-what the person
would like to be and thinks he or she really can be. Depending on the
importance and commitment to these self-definitions desired selves could
define goals and move individuals to action.
- Oftentimes, advertising appeals to a consumer's desired self-concept;
thus, an ad for a Piaget gold watch might appeal to a consumer's desire
to appear wealthy or chic. Exhibit 7.3 shows a decision process that advertisers
might use to create effective advertising.
Exhibit 7.3: Self-Concept and Advertising Effectiveness (50.0K)
- Interpersonal Processes
- Self-concept and the Circle of Consumption
- Self-concept around the World
- Personality
- Personality is best understood as a different idea about the person than
the self. We define personality as the distinctive and enduring
patterns of thoughts, emotions and behaviors that characterize each individual's
adaptation to the situations of his or her life. An individual's consistent
self-representations form the basis for what we understand as personality.
- The study of personality addresses a question critical to all of us: How
can we best judge other people's characters and know what to expect of them?
Early Egyptian, Chinese, and Greek efforts to understand personality relied
on astrology.
- Contemporary interest in personality dates from the 20th century
founder of modern psychology, Sigmund Frued, and his populizers in marketing,
the so-called motivation researchers who were prominent in marketing research
after World War II.
- The long-standing desire to predict behavior based on character traits
endures in personality theory and its consumer behavior applications.
- Traits
- Personality traits are characteristics in which one person differs
from another in a relatively permanent and consistent way. That is,
personality traits are supposed to endure over time (and over situations).
Tests of personality based on measuring so-called personality traits were
initiated during World War I (1914-1918).
- Relative stability is a key aspect of personality traits. In marketing
research, personality is frequently measured with respect to specific traits
such as the Social Character Scale that comes from a study relating the
traits of introversion and extroversion to mass media preferences.
- Recently, a book of consumer behavior scales has been compiled that includes
numerous individual differences shown to affect consumer behavior. Among
the scales represented in this book are: social character, (i.e., inner-
and other-directedness), self-concepts, need for cognition, consumer ethnocentrism,
and the sexual identity scale.
- Inner-directed consumers look to their own inner values and standards
for guiding their behavior. In contrast, other-directed consumers depend
upon the people around them to provide direction for their actions. Thus,
inner-directedness is similar to the trait of introversion (looking internally
for motivation), while other-directedness is similar to extroversion (looking
externally for sources of inspiration).
- Marketers' interest in traits is practical. Do personality traits predict
consumer behavior? One review across numerous studies found that personality
traits only explain about 10% of the variation in consumers' purchase, product
preference, and innovation behaviors. This suggests that trait-based approaches
should be combined with other variables to improve predictions.
- The development of the Five Factor Personality Structures, consisting
of five clusters of traits recently reinvigorated the trait literature.
Research over several decades indicates that the dimensions of Emotional
Stability (or Neuroticism), Extraversion (or outgoingness), Openness to
Exercise, Agreeableness, and Conscientiousness provide a good catalogue
of personality.
- Overall across dozens of studies, the results of trying to relate personality
traits to consumer behaviors have been mixed at best.
- Some approaches for measuring personality traits allow individuals more
leeway to describe themselves in their own ways on dimensions of their own
choosing.
- One innovative tool for studying personality is the personal project.
A personal project is "a set of interrelated acts extending over time
which is intended to maintain or attain a state of affairs foreseen by the
individual. A wide range of related, goal-driven activities might constitute
a personal project. For example, learning to ski, graduating from university,
achieving a career goal, or building a house, are examples of personal projects.
- Self-Esteem and Self-Efficacy
- Self-evaluation, how you feel about yourself, is an important aspect of
personality. Self-evaluations affect the goals you set, your motives, the
anxiety, stress and depression you experience in various situations, and
your selection of preferred environments. Self-esteem is one way
of talking about self-evaluation. Self-esteem is the positivity of a
person's attitude towards him/herself. Self-esteem has been linked to
consumer behavior in a number of important ways.
- Low self-esteem is related to exaggerated concerns with the looking glass
self, the self as viewed through the opinions of others. Quite a bit of
research suggests that consumer culture with its exaggerated emphasis on
the beauty of the physical self may lead to lower self-esteem among consumers.
Low self-esteem in turn is related to compulsive gambling, television addiction,
shoplifting and compulsive buying.
- In contrast to the large numbers of social science research on compulsive
gambling or eating disorders, the investigation of compulsive buyingbehavior is relatively new. We can define compulsive buying behavior
as the inability to restrain the impulse to buy. Reports estimate
that 10 percent of the U.S. population and up to 7 percent of the Mexican
population may be considered compulsive shoppers.
- By contrast, another series of studies show high self-esteem is related
to certain types of spending (not compulsive, however).
- Another way of talking about self-evaluation is self-efficacy. Self-efficacy
is defined as people's beliefs about their capabilities to exercise control
over events that affect their lives.
- Perceived self-efficacy has been linked to numerous cognitive, affective,
and motivational processes. Self-efficacy is also related to affect. Individuals
who do not believe they can exercise control over potential threats experience
high levels of stress and anxiety arousal. Dwelling on these negative and
anxiety arousing images, people low in self-efficacy avoid activities and
social relationships that can then lead to bouts of depression.
- Some research has related self-efficacy to consumer behavior. Several
researchers have suggested that self-efficacy influences decisions involving
technological innovations.
- Self-efficacy should vary cross-culturally.
- Applications to Consumer Behavior Research
- Consumer behavior research is filled with examples of personality trait,
or what are also called individual difference measures. Motivation research
conducted in the 1950's and 1960's examined the relationship between consumers'
perceptions of products and actual or ideal personality traits using self-administrated
questionnaires. In general, it proved difficult to predict consumer brand
choices based on personality traits alone.
- Going beyond the realm of brand choice, personality variables are related
to consumption behaviors. For instance, materialism is related both to impulsive
and compulsive buying behavior. Similarly, self-esteem, need for cognition,
and locus of control are related to the likelihood that a buyer might consult
a friend or expert prior to making a purchase. Self-efficacy is related
to belief in the influence of buying power on social change. Advertisers
often use such personality traits to segment markets.
- Although it may be difficult to predict single instances of behavior with
very much accuracy from personality measures, it may be possible to predict
behavior averaged over a sample of situations and/or occasions. For example,
we cannot predict whether the novelty-seeking trait will lead an individual
consumer to seek out information about a particular new product, but we
might predict that a high level of novelty seeking would lead to higher
levels of new product awareness when averaged over a sample of new products.
Following this approach, advertisers can use personality traits to segment
markets and target their market offerings.
|
|
|