| Chapter Outline (See related pages)
- Community-Based Correction; intermediate sanctions
- Criminal Justice Diversion
- The removal of offenders from the application of the criminal law
at any stage of the police or court process
- The development of diversion
- informal diversion, past and present
- Chicago Boys Court, early example of formalized diversion within
the juvenile justice system
- New York City's Youth Counsel Bureau (early 1950s)
- District of Columbia's Project Crossroads
- Patterns of diversion
- the criminal justice process as a negative influence on offenders
- endorsements of diversion by both the 1967 President's Commission
and the 1973 National Advisory Commission
- expansion of diversion during the 1970s (LEAA)
- youth service bureaus, counseling, tutoring, crisis intervention,
etc.
- public inebriation programs, use of detoxification centers instead
of taking arrested public inebriates to jail
- civil commitment, for some drug users, sexual deviants, and mentally
ill offenders
- citizens dispute settlement, use of mediation to resolve conflict
- Treatment Accountability for Safer Communities (TASC), a bridge
between the criminal justice system and the substance abuse treatment
system
- The impact of diversion—evaluation research is inconclusive
- Community service programs
- Probation
- John August, the father of probation
- The nature of probation
- probation as a sentence (disposition)
- probation as a status, a system, and a process
- The probation philosophy
- nondangerous offenders do not need to be incarcerated for the
protection of the community
- incarceration can make offenders worse
- includes elements of community protection and rehabilitation
- pragmatic issues
- prison overcrowding
- cost of imprisonment
- probation as more humane than prison
- Suspended sentences and conditional release
- withholding the imposition or execution of a court imposed penalty
for a period of time dependent on the offender's good behavior
- suspension of imposition
- suspension of execution
- conditional and unconditional discharge
- The presentence or probation investigation
- probation administered in various ways
- presentence investigation, variations by jurisdiction
- privately commissioned presentence reports
- variations in length and content
- studies indicate a high correlation between probation recommendation
and actual sentence given by the judge
- due process requirement (Williams v. New York)
- Conditions of probation
- state laws prohibiting or permitting probation for some offenses
- factors which influence the prosecutor's and judge's decisions
concerning sentencing
- standard conditions of probation
- special conditions related to offender's needs, crime, or special
circumstances
- requirement for payment of supervision fees
- conditions of probation are generally considered constitutional;
searches governed by Griffin v. Wisconsin (1987)
- Restitution programs
- offenders must repay victims for monetary losses resulting from
the crime
- often used as a condition of probation
- rationales for restitution
- criticisms of restitution
- Probation services
- the casework approach, diagnosis and treatment
- determination of supervision requirements
- quality and quantity of treatment services vary
- reasons for poor quality probation services
- requirements and backgrounds of probation officers vary widely
- probation officer apathy
- low salaries, limited advancement, low level of career mobility
- probation officer attitudes and styles differ considerably
(working styles)
- Shock probation
- brief period of incarceration followed by suspension of sentence
and probation
- arguments in favor of shock probation
- arguments against shock probation
- evaluation research is inconclusive concerning impact on recidivism
- Intensive probation supervision
- closer surveillance and tighter control than traditional probation
- intended to reduce prison crowding and protect society
- intensive supervision in Georgia
- evaluation research shows mixed and ambiguous results
- Probation violation and revocation
- probation as conditional, not absolute, freedom
- new arrest or technical violation can result in revocation
- absconding, failing to report as required, a form of escape
- discretionary authority of probation officer
- only the court can revoke probation
- requirement for due process
- Mempa v. Rhay (1967)
- Morrissey v. Brewer (1972)
- Gagnon v. Scarpelli (1973)
- The effectiveness of probation
- probation is the most widely used sanction
- research has produced contradictory findings; many probationers
are still a threat to the community
- effectiveness may vary considerably from one jurisdiction to
another
- Parole
- The dual nature of parole
- release process
- supervision process
- purposes of parole
- The origins of parole
- Maconochie and Crofton
- "good time" laws
- Zebulon Brockway and the Elmira Reformatory
- Parole administration
- differences between parole and probation
- the parole board
- select offenders for parole
- provide control and supervision
- discharge parolees from supervision
- make revocation decisions
- American Correctional Association recommendations concerning
parole boards
- board members differ greatly in experience with the criminal
justice system
- Eligibility for parole
- parole is not a right
- parole eligibility, earliest date that an inmate can be considered
for parole
- good time as a factor
- the parole hearing
- conducted in private
- procedures vary
- wide discretion
- some due process required; Greenholtz case (1979); Pennsylvania
Board of Probation and Parole v. Scott
- parole selection
- statutory requirements and legislative mandates
- prior record
- institutional conduct
- parole plan
- political influences
- an informed guess
- unpredictability of human behavior
- statistical prediction methods
- scientific parole prediction
- experience tables
- problems with parole prediction tables
- mandatory release
- prosecutor's recommendation
- the role of good time credit
- mandatory release, required by statute upon completion of
sentence
- Conditions of parole
- what the offender must do and what he may not do
- reform conditions and control conditions
- special conditions as with probation
- some conditions have been ruled unconstitutional in recent years
- Parole supervision and services
- parole officer's duty to supervise, aid, and control parolees
- parole officers are armed peace officers in some states
- the difficulty of supervising parolees leads to a quasi-law enforcement
role for the parole officer
- Parole violation and revocation
- similar to probation
- due process requirements; Morrissey v. Brewer
- disagreement over how long the parolee must serve in prison after
revocation
- "street time" and "dead time"
- Parole discharge
- "max out," reach maximum expiration date
- discharged by parole board prior to maximum expiration date;
executive clemency
- pardon by the governor
- The state of parole in the United States
- the role of the parole board has declined
- tremendous growth of the parole population
- the proportion of parole violators as a percentage of total prison
population has increased substantially
- Trends in Community-Based Correction
- Increasing use of community correction, especially for non-violent
offenders
- Furlough and temporary release
- furlough, authorized, unescorted absence from prison for a specified
time period
- home furlough as a means of preparing an inmate for release
- work release, inmate is allowed out of prison to work for pay
in the local community
- study release; similar to work release, but for academic or vocational
education
- experiences with temporary release
- criticisms
- the problem of offenders committing new crimes
- absconding
- risks probably limit wide public acceptance
- halfway houses and prerelease enters
- Should parole be abolished?
- criticisms of parole
- unstructured decision-making
- parole tasks are beyond our capabilities
- we cannot predict future human behavior
- increases sentence disparity
- various theories of the parolee's status
- some states have abolished parole
- what works and what does not work with prisoner reentry
- Summary
|
|